The books I read that would fall under the mystery/suspense genre are few and far between, and I tend to enjoy more character-driven stories rather than action-oriented mysteries. But in a departure from the norm, my library book club chose Tana French’s novel, The Likeness, which was our most recent book. It was not without some trepidation that I began reading, but it wasn’t long before I was under the book’s spell.
There were two things I had to dispel right away, though. Firstly, I had to suspend disbelief that a woman would not just look similiar, but identical to another woman. And not just any two women, but one is an Irish cop and the other has just been found murdered just miles away. The other was the sense that I’d read this book before, a literary déjà vu if you will, since the situation and characters bears more than a passing resemblance to Donna Tartt’s suspenseful and sinister novel, The Secret History. In fact, in post-reading research, I learned that Tartt’s novel is one of French’s favorites and one of her influences.
But don’t let those two issues deter you from reading The Likeness. It’s a cracking good read in its own right and implausability issues aside, it has a suspenseful plot that held my interest for all of its 480 pages.
Cassie Maddox is a young Irish detective, working in the domestic violence departments after stints in undercover and homicide, respectively. Her boyfriend, Sam, a homicide detective, calls her out to an Irish village on the outskirts of Dublin to a dilapidated cottage where a young woman has been found murdered. The dead girl has been identified as Lexie Madison, a pseudonym that Cassie used when she was undercover. Sam, who thought at first that it was Cassie who was dead, is rattled even further when Frank, an undercover detective and Cassie’s former boss, suggests that pulling the old switcheroo on Cassie and the dead girl would be the perfect way to solve the murder. After undergoing preparations to assume the dead girl’s identity, Cassie/Lexie returns to the village manor house she shares with four other post-graduate students, to discover who killed her doppelgänger. Suspects and motives are both unclear, and the line between professional and personal is also blurred, as Cassie delves into Lexie’s insular and enigmatic life.
The Likeness is French’s second novel, after the award-winning In the Woods, which also features Cassie Maddox. Although not strictly a sequel, French does allude to the events of the prior book, but in a way that does not divulge too much but instead incites a desire to read the first book and find out exactly what made Cassie into the person she is when we meet her in The Likeness.
The Likeness also serves as my third entry into this year’s RIP Challenge, which means I have just a few days to read and blog about another suitable book, which you never know, just may happen. Stay tuned!






















I read this one earlier this year and absolutely loved it. Tana French has swiftly become one of my favorite novelists, and while I do generally enjoy mystery novels, I don’t tend to read the more crime/CSI oriented ones, which I feel her books are… but I just love the psychological depths she explores and how lushly atomospheric her writing is. I’ll certainly be reading the next book, which is supposed to follow Cassie’s old boss, Frank. In The Woods is a really strong debut, but if I had to choose between the two, I’d say The Likeness is the better of the two
One of my book club members mentioned that she was coming out with a third novel that focused on one of her existing characters, but couldn’t remember who – my money was on Frank, since he’s so enigmatic. I can’t wait to read it! I’m curious, did you read The Likeness before or after In the Woods? I wonder if reading order has anything to do with preference.
I read The Likeness after In The Woods, and while I think my reading experience of it was certainly enriched by having first read In The Woods (so I already had some knowledge of Cassie), I think that in general it is just a better novel. In The Woods was French’s debut, so I think she was still working out some kinks there, even though it is remarkably strong. The Likeness just seemed more tightly plotted in my eyes.
But really both are great and I proudly own the two and am sure I’ll reread both in the future.
Thanks for responding. It seemed to me that a lot of the negative Amazon reviews for The Likeness were from readers who read and loved In the Woods, so it’s good to hear a dissenting opinion on that.
There was quite a bit of hype about Tana French earlier this year. I read In the Woods, and liked it, but didn’t love it. Have to say that I totally enjoyed this one. I loved how Rob from In the Woods was a character in this book without ever making an appearance.
Can’t wait for the next book from her!
It seems that preference between the two books is split. I loved how she didn’t give away too much of what happens in In the Woods but just teased you enough to make you want to read it.
I read In the Woods and liked it a lot. This one is in my TBR pile.
I want to read In the Woods now but it will probably be awhile before I actually do – too many books, so little time!
I really liked In the Woods and so did The Hubster. I know enough about this one to agree with you on the having to suspend disbelief a bit on the lookalike thing, but I’m glad to hear that you still liked the book.
It’s not hard to do (suspending disbelief) but I did keep expecting her to come out with a reason, however indirect, for the resemblance.
I have my grandmother reading Tana French, but I have not read her yet myself.
Was it the Irish setting or the suspense aspect that you felt would most appeal to her?
Hmmm. I’m glad you said it might be possible to read this without reading In the Woods first. I have both, but I’ve heard The Likeness is better so I might start on that one.
I was a little leery of recommending it for the book club for just that reason, but all comments I read that spoke to that said it wasn’t necessary. I did let folks know ahead of time so they could read the first one beforehand if they wanted – but I don’t think any of them did. But more than one has gone on to read it now!
I came here via Aarti’s blog and you’ve already gotten me to get three books! (Into the Woods, The Likeness & The Observations.) I think I shouldn’t read any more of your reviews…;)
Thanks for visiting! I know that feeling – sometimes there is such a think as book overload!
I’ve only read her first book, but have this one waiting patiently for me to pick up. I’m glad to hear that you enjoyed it!
I’ll be curious to see which one you prefer!
I loved both of French’s books (The Likeness a bit more than In the Woods) and hope it isn’t too long before she publishes the third (featuring Frank, I believe). I hope to see more of Cassie in the third installment!
Yes, I think the third one does focus on Frank, which is good as he was such an enigmatic and intriguing character in The Likeness. I agree that I hope Cassie also makes a significant appearance.