With all the cold and rainy weather we’ve been having lately here in Georgia (yes, I know, it doesn’t compare to the subzero temperatures my family is experiencing back home in Canada, but it’s still miserable!), opening the pages of Julia Gregson’s novel East of the Sun was akin to lighting a roaring fire in a cold, damp room. I could almost soak up the heat from the book’s locale just by reading its pages. And isn’t the cover gorgeous?
In 1920s England, Viva is an aspiring writer who longs to return to India, where she lived until her parents were tragically and mysteriously killed when she was a young girl. To afford the cost of the trip, she hires herself out as chaperone to two young women, Rose, who is traveling to India to marry her soldier fiance, and her bridesmaid and best friend, Victoria, who is hoping to escape the confines of her mother’s control and find herself a husband among the eligible British living in Bombay. Viva also takes on 16-year-old Guy Glover, a troubled and strange boy who is being sent back to his parents after being expelled from yet another British boarding school. Once on board the ship that will take them to India, the three women share their hopes and dreams for what they believe India harbors for each of them and experience a freedom unknown to them back in England. When they actually arrive in Bombay, the realities of their new existence, in the last days of a colonial empire, are much different than they anticipated.
The book’s strengths lie in the parts devoted Viva, Tor and Rose and the ways in which they forge new lives for themselves. What is less successful is the character of Guy Glover, who I felt had no other role except to add unnecessary conflict and problems – which he does, in spades. But it was a little too much to add into what, at over 600 pages, is already a book with a lot going on: the changing role of women in society and the class disparity both in England and in India to name but two. Also, while we catch glimpses into the social and political upheavals taking place in India during this time, since the women are on the periphery of these events, we see things from their limited perspective and so end up feeling like there’s a lot we’re missing just beyond the margins. But those are minor complaints in comparison to what was truly a captivating story and a welcome burst of light into what has been rather dark reading of late.























Sounds lovely. I’m always up to read historical fiction and books that take me to another culture.
It is quite good, Lisa – very nice for this time of year, too. It will definitely chase the winter chill away!
It does have a beautiful cover. Looks like an interesting book. I might need to check that one out!
It’s definitely worth borrowing a copy from the library, and although it’s a chunkster (over 600 pages – so if you’re doing that challenge it would qualify) it reads very quickly.
I really, really liked this one too! I agree that Guy was an annoyance, but overall such an enjoyable read.
Yeah, I could have done without him, or downplay him or make him just the usual annoyance, rather than adding the mental health aspect. But even with that it was a book that kept me entertained.
I really enjoyed this book – even though it was long, I wanted to keep reading!
Yep, I’m with you on that – their stories were so interesting. And in spite of myself, I wondered what happened to Guy. For such a pivotal character, she kind of just left him in the dust.
So excited to check out this book!!! I am an India buff. The Namesake, Interpreter of Maladies, Unaccustomed Earth, Marrying Anita, The Space Between Us … all excellent. I love reading about India. I will definitely check out East of the Sun, thanks for the recommendation! BTW – Really liked the Marian Keyes “The Brightest Star in the Sky”. Sort of surreal, fairy godmother stuff, but good enough to take you away. Why not take a break from reality?! Right!! I mentioned it was a lot like Cecilia Ahern (whom I adore). She is the daughter of the former prime minister of Ireland and has written a slew of best sellers, ie PS I Love You and the show Samantha Who, she is only 28! Check out the books, I have surprisingly enjoyed these magical books!
I am currently reading The Kids Are All Right (memoir) for my book club. Will let you know. Happy New Year! And heres to the best books we shall find in 2010!
Karen, have you read any books by Thrity Umrigar or Ruth Prawer Jhabvala? Their books would help satisfy your penchant for Indian literature. Glad to hear you are enjoying the Ahern and Keyes books so much! Happy Reading in 2010!
I totally agree with your review. Really enjoyed most of it, but didn’t think that the character of Guy worked all that well.
I subsequently read her earlier book The Water Horse, and thought that that was an excellent read too.
Yes, she definitely could have left him out entirely and I would have enjoyed the book even more. I’ll have to take a look at The Water Horse since you like that one, too.
I enjoyed this book a lot–it had a different flavor to it so it was a nice change of pace. And I agree, the cover is gorgeous!
Did you happen to visit the sites the author mentions at the back of the book? The photos of old Bombay are particularly interesting, and helped with the visualization of Tor, Rose and Viva’s surroundings. (Even though I didn’t visit the site until after the fact!)
I can’t decide if I want to read this or not… It sounds good, but then it doesn’t at the same time.
If you like historical fiction, particularly if it deals with India, women’s lives or early 20th century, then I highly recommend it. It’s a hefty book but it reads really fast.
I’m dying to read this! But it keeps being checked out of my library – I always want to read more books about the Raj. It’s such a weird and fascinating piece of British/Indian history.
I hope a copy comes in soon! It’s a perfect cure for the winter chill. Gregson does a really good job of showing the different emotions the British living in India had towards the country – some with disdain, others with affection, and the cultural differences between the Indians and the colonists. Interesting stuff indeed!
Wow–this is a very intriguing book. I am surprised I never heard of it before. I must, must, must locate a copy.
I don’t think it’s gotten a lot of press on this side of the Atlantic. I don’t even remember how I came to know about it. I’ll be curious to knw what you think of it if/when you read it.
Oh, yes! Definitely going on the list!
Great! I’ll be curious to see what you think of it and how it compares to the DiRollo book.
I really enjoyed this book!! Thanks for the recommendation! I was certainly disturbed by Guy Glovers character but I feel he added a mysterious twist to an otherwise predictable set of romances. I thoroughly enjoy books about India and the British so this was a great mix for me! (Long but good!) I am now reading Push by Sapphire. Check it out. From page one you are hooked by this girls story. (BTW – I did not see the movie)
Glad you enjoyed it! It wasn’t adding in a character to provide conflict that bothered me about Guy (I agree, I think it’s good to have a antigonist in there to shake things up) but just the way in which he was depicted, I think could have been better, and the way he just petered out at the end was kind of strange to me.
I have Push on my TBR list but I will have to wait for the hold list at our library to whittle down, which may take a while!