I first starting reading the buzz about David Ebershoff’s novel The 19th Wife last summer, and recognized his name from another book I’ve had on my wishlist, The Danish Girl. I tucked the title away in the back of my mind as a possible future read, and that was that.
Then earlier this year I was contacted by TLC Book Tours as a possible reviewer for The 19th Wife. As with other book bloggers, I regularly get contacted by reps and authors wanting me to review their books. Typically, I don’t – I have enough books on my TBR stack to keep me going pretty much until the end of time. But The 19th Wife had intrigued me back when I first heard about it, and so I gratefully accepted. Once my review copy arrived, I spent a few moments savoring its bulk – more than 500 pages – which meant this was a story I could really immerse myself in. I was in the middle of planning library anniversary events at the time, and knew I wouldn’t be able to really enjoy the book if I had to limit myself to a few pages here and there. So I saved it for a time when I knew I would: my vacation. On the Memorial Day weekend, we flew to Virginia to spend several days with friends, and I started the book on the plane. I was immediately drawn into the story, and over the next few days, stayed up late each night reading, luxuriating in the knowledge that I didn’t have to worry about work or other mundane realities of life. Is there anything better than vacation reading?
The book is part historical fiction, part “ripped from the headlines” contemporary novel, and alternates back and forth between time periods and the different characters. Now, I know some people don’t like this tactic; I’ve had people say to me that they find it confusing. Personally, I quite enjoy layering a story in this manner, and seeing the parallels and connections between the two. There are actually two 19th wives in this novel: Ann Eliza Young, one of the Mormon prophet Brigham Young’s wives, and the other is a plural wife from a polygamous sect in rural Utah, accused of murdering her husband.
Ann Eliza, who did in fact exist, and in the 1870s wrote a book, Wife No. 19, exposing the Mormon practice of polygamy to the world, a practice which up to that point was mainly the stuff of rumor and suspicion, and played a part having the practice outlawed by the United States and banned by the church itself. Ebershoff delves into her life, from her youth as a devout Mormon, through her struggle with the tenet of celestial marriage, and eventual renunciation of her faith. He also shows us the greater society in which Ann Eliza lived, and the effects – both positive and negative – that early Mormonism had on its followers.
In the 21st century, Jordan Scott is a “lost boy,” a young man who several years earlier was kicked out of his community, left on the side of a lonely desert road one night by his own mother. Now living in Los Angeles, he discovers that his mother has been arrested, accused of murdering his father. Even though she abandoned him all those years ago, he goes back to Utah to see her, and find out what really happened. Along the way he befriends another “lost boy” and even manages to find a love interest. Jordan’s story is interesting, not just for the murder mystery aspect, but for the issues it alludes to for Mormonism: reconciling past practices with current beliefs, the existence of polygamous sects who claim to be the true Latter-Day Saints, the treatment of women and homosexuals in the modern church, and how the religion is viewed by society today.
The 19th Wife is a rich, layered tale, much like the history of Mormonism itself. For me, the best historical fiction blends fact and fiction together so expertly that I don’t know where one ends and the other begins, and that is just what Ebershoff has done with this novel. Reading this kind of historical fiction compels me to go out and search for the truth behind the story, which is just what I did as soon as I turned the last page of this book. There are some great resources on the book’s official website, as well as information about the author, his upcoming appearances and other books. Also, I love that authors and publishers are now starting to do book trailers (previews are always my favorite part about going to the movies) and there’s a great one for The 19th Wife.
The lovely and well-read Iliana over at Bookgirl’s Nightstand will be reviewing this book tomorrow, so be sure to stop by and read her thoughts on the book. (I’m definitely curious!)
Oh, and one more thing: you can win your very own copy of The 19th Wife! Just leave a comment on this post by this Friday, June 5th, and I’ll draw for the winner. Good luck! Edit: The winner has been chosen and it is Carrie K! Congrats and I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did!






















Sounds like an excellent read!
It was indeed!
I enjoyed your review. This book caught my attention early on but with my pile already toppling over, it sort of got pushed to the wayside. I will re-think that and move it up a bit.
I would love to win it!
I do that a lot, especially working in a library and then book blogging on top of it, there are only so many books I can read and then all these other great-sounding books get pushed to the wayside – or even completely off the list. Oh well, there are definitely worse problems to have.
What a great vacation read! This has been on my list for a while but I just can’t seem to get around to acquiring it. I would love to win it! Thanks for a great review.
It was a great book to dive into and spend some quality vacation time reading. Thanks!
Smart idea saving this one for vacation. Excellent review!
This sounds really interesting; I’d love to win a copy!
It was really interesting, a good summer read.
This looks like a good one! Added it to my Goodreads TBR shelf!
I hope you enjoy it, too.
I love back-and-forth books, particularly if the tension is done just right. I saw a piece on PBS about gays and lesbians who consider themselves Mormons, even if the official church doesn’t. I love any story that asks us to call into question who belongs and who doesn’t…and what is the price of exiling yourself from the community you’re born into?
Martha, very good points and I think Ebershoff does an excellent job of writing about that dichotomy and struggle to stay part of a community while staying true to yourself.
For another really good back-and-forth book, try People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks.
Please enter me! I have heard so much about this book and would love to read it!
Thanks for the review! I am a big fan of HBO’s BIG LOVE, and am curious to read about more about Mormonism and all of its various offshoots.
Please enter me in the contest and thanks for hosting it.
I haven’t seen that show (we don’t subscribe to HBO) although I’ve heard a lot about it. If you’re interested in Mormon history/perspectives, a good non-fiction memoir is Riding in the Shadow of Saints by Jana Richman.
This sounds interesting and I’d like to win the book!
This book does look really good. It is on my TBR pile. I should really get around to reading it!
I’ve had this on my wish list since I read the very first review I came across – I’d love to win a copy. Thanks for the giveaway!
This book is in my TBR pile. I would love to win a copy!
Melissa, I hope you get around to reading it someday and that you like it as much as I did.
I just checked this book out of the library on a whim, and LOVE IT! I have even gone online to check out some of his facts, and found the original 19th wife book by Ann Eliza Young, so interesting! I am only to page 164, so I can’t really recommend the entire book, but the first 164 pages are great!
Libbie, I did the same thing after reading this book. The actual history is so fascinating. I’m surprised there’s not more factual material written about her.
Lesley, Lesley. You’ve done it again! Now I want to read this.
Hey, just doing my part to add to everyone’s TBR mountains!
I absolutely loved this book. I also enjoyed the back-to-back of the two stories and found it extremely interesting. I am fascinated by the Mormon religion. Thank you for including the information about Ann Eliza Young; I had wanted to do some research to see if she was a real person and how true those portions of the book are.
The factual information on Ann Eliza Young and the early Mormon church is fascinating. For another good book on Mormonism from a personal perspective, try ‘Riding in the Shadow of Saints’ by Jana Richman.
Every review I read makes me want this book more. Vacation reading with time to devote to it sounds like a good approach. Thanks for a great review!
Vacation time is prime reading time. There’s nothing like a big, fat book to dive into and just get away from it all.
So glad to hear you enjoyed it! I loved reading your review and I agree on the multi-layering and how the blending of fact and fiction worked so well. To me, it just made me feel not only like I was entertained but that I’d learn something about religion and history in America!
I agree, Iliana – I thought it was a great blend of fact and fiction and I couldn’t wait to go out and do the factual research after I finished the book. Glad you enjoyed it as well!
Thanks for the review. Would love to win a copy. Have a great weekend.
Nice review! I always love hearing about a new book & I would love to read it myself! please count me in!
Thank you so much – I am really excited to read this one.:)
I hope you enjoy it!
Hello~
I have just started reading “The 19th Wife” and I agree: the story just grabs you!! The last novel I read that was this many pages was “The Emperor of Ocean Park” by Stephen L. Carter (great read) so I was hesitant. But so glad I picked it up from the library. And I also love layered writing and tales.
Thank you so much for the review
Love your blog–it’s fantastic!
Gayla L.
Las Vegas
I haven’t read anything by Stephen Carter but I’ve heard good things about New England White. Thanks for stopping by!