I’d wanted to read The Myth of You and Me since Susan recommended it, after reading it for her book club. So, when it was chosen as the selection for my book club this month, I was quite excited. I started reading it yesterday afternoon and stayed up into the wee hours of the night, unable to put it down until I finished it.
There were several things I loved about this book. First, the friendship between Cameron, who is telling the story, and Sonia, her estranged best friend, and the ways in which the author brings to light the bonds between women, how strong and yet how fragile those friendships can be.
I felt a particular connection to Cameron, for her distant and troublesome relationship with her father, her admission of never having been a daddy’s girl, never having been his princess or baby, and her mixture of longing and scorn for those daughters who did have that kind of bond with their fathers. It makes me wonder if there perhaps my experience is not as unusual as I thought. Her compulsion to never put down roots, to continually be on the move, also resonated with me:
“I felt the stirrings of a certain familiar excitement – the anticipation of departure. [...] With moving, I have always been partial to the in-between, the blurred highway outside the window, that suspended time when everything you were lies behind you like a molted skin, and everything you might become shimmers at the horizon. You might choose anything and make it happen, constrained by nothing but your own imagination, sure that not even gravity can hold you.“
And then later, commenting that “… it’s easy to believe you’ve left behind not just a place but everything you felt there, even grief.”
I also loved the disparate settings of rural North Carolina and the contrasting Massachusetts environment. Cameron’s observation about the New England coastline captures the essence of this difference in northern and southern sensibilities: “This was not one of the mild, welcoming southern beaches I was used to, but an imposing one, where you seemed more likely to drown than to dog-paddle.”
Cameron’s recounting of the destruction of her friendship with Sonia, the reconcilation of her past with not only her present but also her future, and the ways in which we deceive not only others, but ourselves, makes for a truly enjoyable reading experience. I can’t wait to hear what my fellow bookclubbers thought of it, and if it impacted any of them in a similar way.






















I wish I’d thought about this book when we organized our list for this coming year. I’ll be anxious to see how your discussion goes. I loved this book, it had some excellent observations about friendship, and it made me think about relationships in my past.
I have this on my Amazon wishlist, but now feel compelled to rush out to B&N and get a copy ASAP. Lots of issues resonating with me – the father/daughter connection; the estrangement between friends; and the itchy feet to move on rather than set down roots. I, too, will be anxious to read more about how your bookclubbers felt about the novel. Please keep us posted.
I’m glad you enjoyed it, Lesley… I’m interested to know what you thought when the big secret of what drove them apart was revealed.
Leah Stewart called in to our book club (you could probably have her call into yours) and I challenged her on it, since I thought it was a total cop out, cliche reason for two best friends to come apart like that…
She stated it was based on experience.
Susan
Susan, I was a bit disappointed when the secret was revealed, but then I thought about it more and in the context of the characters, it did make sense to me. I’ll email you offline to chat more, since I don’t want to give anything away.
I just finished this, and while it wasn’t fantastic, I still cried a little..
Sounds like one that needs to be added to “The List”. That’s cool that the author called your bookclub, Susan.