Although I haven’t yet read Kate Morton’s previous novel, The House at Riverton, as soon as I saw her latest book, The Forgotten Garden, on the New Books table at the bookstore, I knew I wanted to read it. Even more so when I read the jacket blurb which made the book sound like a grown-up version of The Secret Garden mixed with a dollop of Du Maurier-esque Gothic suspense.
In 1913 Australia, a little girl is found abandoned in a sea-side town, and all that’s known about her is that she arrived on a ship from England. The girl knows only that a mysterious woman she called The Authoress brought her on board the ship and hid her away. The portmaster brings the girl home and he and his wife name her Nell and raise her as their own daughter. Years later when Nell is told about how she came to be part of their family, she embarks on a quest to find out her real identity. But it is left to Nell’s granddaughter, Cassandra, to retrace her grandmother’s footsteps, to delve into the secrets of the past, unearthing the truth among the cliffs of Cornwall and the imposing Blackhurst Manor. The common thread throughout the novel is a collection of stories written by Eliza Makepeace, a forgotten Edwardian writer of enigmatic and enchanting fairy tales, some of which are laced throughout the novel, offering tantalzing clues and further mysteries. At the heart of the book and the mystery is the manor’s cottage garden, which is both a symbolic and tangible link to Nell’s past.
The Forgotten Garden is an atmospheric, superb story, one that offers fans of Sarah Waters, Diane Setterfield and the great Gothic writers a worthy and rewarding reading experience. It was also the perfect way for me to begin this year’s RIP Challenge. Oh, and The House at Riverton? A copy is on my nightstand, waiting to be read.






















I am soooo happy to hear you liked this! I have this on my shelf and I was really excited to read it when I bought it. But, then I heard a few bad things about it and I didn’t pick it up as soon as I’d wanted to. Your review has reinvigorated my excitement. I don’t think I have enough time left in the month to read it for the RIP IV challenge, but it’s definitely back at the top of my list. Great review. =)
Really? I’ll have to go look around for other reviews. I hadn’t read anything – negative or positive – about the book prior to reading it, and with the exception of coincidentally talking to someone at a dinner party the other night who was in the middle of reading (and enjoying) it, I haven’t met anyone who’s even heard of the book, let alone read it!
I thought of The Secret Garden when I saw the cove! The setting of this book sounds wonderful, Cornwall etc. and I love that there is a mystery in the story but it isn’t about crime and there is a garden that is important to the story!
Great post!
I wonder if the connection to The Secret Garden was intentional, probably so, I would imagine. The Cornish coast must be quite a romantic spot – so many Gothic-type novels are set there! I’m reminded of one of my favorite authors as a teenager – Barbara Michaels – who set many of her books there.
I can’t make up my mind if I want to read this or not. You do make it sound really good, though!
It’s a good fall/winter read, I think. Have you read her earlier book?
Ooh, this sounds right up my alley. I will certainly be searching it out! A Secret Garden meets Du Maurier? Sign me up.
I’ll be curious to know what you think of it if you do end up reading it, Daphne.
I agree with Daphne – Secret Garden was one of my all-time favourites, and I’ve just discovered du Maurier. Sounds fantastic.
I’ve never actually read The Secret Garden, I just saw the movie (the one starring Kate Maberly and Maggie Smith) which I adored.
I’m also a late-comer to the DuMaurier party – I read Rebecca a couple years ago and absolutely loved it. Haven’t read anything else by her, though, and should remedy that. I just fear nothing will live up to Rebecca.
this is in my tbr pile. I didn’t realize when I bought it that it was the same author who did the house at riverton, which I had bought and read shortly after I read the 13th tale. Possible because it was right after 13th Tale (that I love love love).. that the house at Riverton did not stand up to the likes of Diane Setterfield in the least. But.. this review gives me hope that maybe her second attempt does! I will push it up on the list!
Hmm, I wonder what I’ll think of House of Riverton, in comparison to The Thirteenth Tale – while I greatly enjoyed the latter, I don’t think I loved it quite as much as you did!
Now I’m really intrigued – I’m going to have to look for both of these!
Then the only question remains, which will you read first?
I just finished reading Rebecca by DuMaurier so this one sounds like one I would thoroughly enjoy…beautiful cover too!
Isn’t it though? It caught my eye as soon as I saw it on the table. I’d heard of the book through prepub notifications beforehand, but actually seeing it in person convinced me to buy it.
I would probably give yourself some distance between Rebecca and The Forgotten Garden, though – the former is so great that pretty much anything pales in comparison!
I really liked The House at Riverton and have The Forgotten Garden on my nightstand. I hope to squeeze it in soon. I’m glad to hear good things about it.
I can’t wait to read The House at Riverton – I have a few books ahead of it on the stack but I hope I enjoy it as much as I did her latest. And I’m glad to hear you enjoyed Riverton, too!
I enjoyed The House at Riverton a lot, although I did get a bit annoyed with the writing style by the end. Definitely want to read The Forgotten Garden though as it sounds like such fun.
What was it about the writing style that you didn’t like? If you can answer that without giving anything away, of course! I wonder how the two books compare. Hopefully I’ll find out soon enough!
I’m not terribly familiar with these books, but that cover is LUSCIOUS! That’s the only word I can come up with. I’m a sucker for a good cover–that’s for sure.
I know, I love the sepia-toned image and all. It IS luscious! I’m glad we don’t live back in the day when books all had the same binding. Even today I can’t imagine removing the dust jackets from my books and shelving them without their covers.
I really liked The House at Riverton and am so happy to see another one by Kate Morton. Especially after this review!
I’m glad to hear you enjoyed The House at Riverton so much, Jen – it makes me want to read it even more!
This sounds like it has everything I like in fiction. The era, the mystery and the gothic. I have the House at Riverton on my TBR pile and now can’t wait to read it. Then I’ll just have to get The Forgotten Garden afterwards!
I haven’t been able to start House at Riverton yet but I am so looking forward to it and just a little scared that it won’t live up to my (probably inflated) expectations. Hope you enjoy the books, too!